Fixing Hubbert Linearization

Peak oil curves are largely based on a model called Hubbert Linearization. Some critics claim that this model is incorrect. The fix may be as simple as assuming a slight positive skew on the production curve.

Here is the Hubbert Linearization for oil production in the Lower 48 United States:

You’ll notice that although the latter data points appear very linear, the early data points are grossly underestimated. What could explain this? Well, let’s look at the production curve upon which it is based:

Notice that errors of the normal curve model are systematic. The early, high positive curve part consistently overestimates. The positive slope, consistently underestimates. The negative slope consistently overestimates. We can see the beginnings of the high positive curve tail part underestimating the actual end-game production.

If so, we can place a positive skew on the production curve to get a curve that may be more realistic:

There may be additional corrections required in the other major moments (more kurtosis, for example), but they won’t affect the overall prediction:

Peak oil is real (under its assumption of geological fluid recovery) and, Hubbert Linearization is understimating the terminal production.

Bottom line: There may be a little more “breathing room” than predicted by normal peak oil theory.

Posted by James Bowery on Thursday, February 4, 2010 at 12:25 AM in
Comments (0) | Tell a friend

Comments:

No comments yet.

Next entry: A reply to Ozy

Previous entry: The Bear's Lair: Let's Atomize Wall Street

Existential Issues

Of note

Recent Comments

PF commented in entry 'Romilly Jenkins: Truth and 'Ethnic' Truth' on 03/18/10, 04:10 AM. (go) (view)

PF commented in entry ''Enlightened' Child Abuse' on 03/18/10, 02:39 AM. (go) (view)

Wandrin commented in entry 'Europe's Future: Is this what "they" want?' on 03/18/10, 02:17 AM. (go) (view)

Wandrin commented in entry 'Serious Crime - The Ethnic Dimension; Fact and Fantasy' on 03/18/10, 01:45 AM. (go) (view)

Gorboduc commented in entry ''Enlightened' Child Abuse' on 03/18/10, 01:24 AM. (go) (view)

Guessedworker commented in entry ''Enlightened' Child Abuse' on 03/18/10, 12:35 AM. (go) (view)

Borvo commented in entry 'Europe's Future: Is this what "they" want?' on 03/17/10, 11:44 PM. (go) (view)

PF commented in entry 'Diasporal Hijinks: Christopher Hitchens and the Janjaweed' on 03/17/10, 10:31 PM. (go) (view)

Maximilio commented in entry 'Is Dr. David Duke, Ph.D., a Kosher Nazi?' on 03/17/10, 10:12 PM. (go) (view)

Gorboduc commented in entry ''Enlightened' Child Abuse' on 03/17/10, 08:01 PM. (go) (view)

PF commented in entry ''Enlightened' Child Abuse' on 03/17/10, 07:44 PM. (go) (view)

Robert Reis commented in entry 'Europe's Future: Is this what "they" want?' on 03/17/10, 07:29 PM. (go) (view)

PF commented in entry 'Blowing Bubbles' on 03/17/10, 07:27 PM. (go) (view)

Dan Dare commented in entry 'Blowing Bubbles' on 03/17/10, 06:33 PM. (go) (view)

Dan Dare commented in entry 'Blowing Bubbles' on 03/17/10, 05:44 PM. (go) (view)

Gorboduc commented in entry 'Blowing Bubbles' on 03/17/10, 05:22 PM. (go) (view)

g commented in entry 'Blowing Bubbles' on 03/17/10, 05:06 PM. (go) (view)

Gorboduc commented in entry ''Enlightened' Child Abuse' on 03/17/10, 03:16 PM. (go) (view)

Guessedworker commented in entry ''Enlightened' Child Abuse' on 03/17/10, 02:30 PM. (go) (view)

DRS commented in entry 'Blowing Bubbles' on 03/17/10, 02:22 PM. (go) (view)

James Bowery commented in entry 'Serious Crime - The Ethnic Dimension; Fact and Fantasy' on 03/17/10, 02:00 PM. (go) (view)

Gorboduc commented in entry ''Enlightened' Child Abuse' on 03/17/10, 01:45 PM. (go) (view)

MsAnnThrope commented in entry 'A genocide in South Africa' on 03/17/10, 12:17 PM. (go) (view)

Lurker commented in entry 'A genocide in South Africa' on 03/17/10, 11:42 AM. (go) (view)

Guessedworker commented in entry ''Enlightened' Child Abuse' on 03/17/10, 11:35 AM. (go) (view)

Gorboduc commented in entry 'Serious Crime - The Ethnic Dimension; Fact and Fantasy' on 03/17/10, 10:37 AM. (go) (view)

Gorboduc commented in entry ''Enlightened' Child Abuse' on 03/17/10, 10:18 AM. (go) (view)

MsAnnThrope commented in entry 'A genocide in South Africa' on 03/17/10, 09:53 AM. (go) (view)

Eddie Booth commented in entry 'Serious Crime - The Ethnic Dimension; Fact and Fantasy' on 03/17/10, 09:12 AM. (go) (view)

Søren Renner commented in entry 'Saturday Riddle Classic' on 03/17/10, 03:12 AM. (go) (view)

mossydottir commented in entry 'Saturday Riddle Classic' on 03/17/10, 03:08 AM. (go) (view)

Guessedworker commented in entry ''Enlightened' Child Abuse' on 03/17/10, 01:12 AM. (go) (view)

Gupta commented in entry 'The Indian/Chinese IQ puzzle' on 03/17/10, 12:25 AM. (go) (view)

Gorboduc commented in entry 'Saturday Riddle Classic' on 03/16/10, 11:57 PM. (go) (view)

Gorboduc commented in entry ''Enlightened' Child Abuse' on 03/16/10, 11:34 PM. (go) (view)

General News

Science News

Science Categories

All Categories

The Writers

Each author's name links to a list of all articles posted by the writer; the hashes link to authors' homepages.

Links

Endorsement not implied.

Crime

General

Immigration

Islam

Jews

Nationalist Political Parties

New Right

Science

Whites in Africa