The Indian/Chinese IQ puzzle

Both India and China are countries that have had the sort of moderate contact with the rest of Eurasia that their position at two extremities of Asia would lead one to expect.  Both India and China have had their own sophisticated civilizations for at least two thousand years.  The Chinese invented such things as gunpowder and printing.  The Indians invented the so-called “Arabic” numerals that we use to this day and one of their religions (Buddhism) has been enormously influential outside their own borders.  Both Indians and Chinese do extremely well economically outside their home countries.  To me this is a picture of two generally intelligent populations.  Yet the average IQ score for the two differs markedy.  Chinese score somewhat above the Western norm and Indians score markedly below it.  How come? 

The usual explanation of IQ in terms of climate is straightforward.  India has a much warmer climate than China and the severe Northern Chinese winter has selected heavily for ability to think ahead and intelligence generally.  Consonant with that, it is only Northern East Asians (the Han Chinese, the Koreans and the Japanese) that have the IQ advantage.  Southern East Asians (Filipinos, Malayans and Vietnamese) are if anything slightly below the British/American norm.

As a very criterion-oriented psychometrician, however, I am not really convinced by that explanation.  I know Indians very well and I have even done social surveys in India.  And I cannot convince myself that Indians suffer any real disadvantage.  I am inclined to the view that the difference we see lies in the non-genetic causes of intelligence.  Since a third of intelligence is NOT genetically determined, environmental factors would be well able to explain the measured IQ differences between Indians and Chinese.

So what could be the environmental factors that differ?  Here we are as far as I can see entirely in the realm of speculation.  The difference that occurs to me is the legendary Chinese devotion to education—which goes back long before significant Western contact.  Even in the days of Marco Polo (Yes.  I know that the Marco Polo tale is probably a compilation from various sources) entry to the Imperial Chinese civil service was via examination.  India, by contrast, has nothing comparable.  There was some stress on education during the British Raj but the Raj (or “Reich”, as the Germans would say) had nearly complete control of India for not much more than a hundred years (the Sepoy mutiny was in 1857).  What DOES characterize the Indians as far as I can see is an enormous devotion to chat.  The Indians are as talkative as the Chinese and Japanese are reserved.  So it always amuses me to see the different contributions that the Indians and Chinese are now making to the globalized economy.  The Chinese have become the workshop of the world and now supply all the widgets and gadgets that anyone could need.  Our supermarkets are full of their manufactures.  And what do the Indians export?  TALK!  They are the call-centre headquarters of the world!  How fitting!

And note that verbal ability is the core element in IQ.  If you want a quick index of IQ, vocabulary size is the best available shortcut measure.  So that fact too militates against Indians really being dumb.

So what I think has happened is that the Indians have the depressed IQ scores that are characteristic of an overwhelmingly rural population (scores which rise with urbanization) but in China an equally rural population has overcome the rural handicap by an emphasis on education skills—and those skills help to maximize IQ scores.

The lower scores of the Southern East Asians are usually explaimed by pointing to a history of interbreeding with pre-existing indigenous populations and I suspect that the Negritos (pygmies) are the main culprit there.  Filipino and Vietnamese women in particular are still often remarkably short by our standards.

Posted by jonjayray on Saturday, January 1, 2005 at 03:10 AM in Psychology
Trackbacks (0) | Comments (78) | Tell-a-Friend

The trackback URL for this entry is: http://majorityrights.com/index.php/trackback/237/mfsuOhNp/

Trackbacks:

No trackbacks yet.

Comments:

Page 1 of 1 pages


jon,

one should focus on the populations of trinidad, guyana, mauritius and fiji for a representative of south asian IQ outside of south asian poverty, as these populations are drawn from the peasants of northern india by an large (rather than elites).  what little i know suggests there is some improvement, but still well below the white median.

Posted by razib on Sunday, January 2, 2005 at 03:36 AM | #


Fiji would be interesting as they are quite prosperous there

Posted by John Ray on Sunday, January 2, 2005 at 05:50 AM | #


Fiji would be interesting as they are quite prosperous there

well...their industry is measured i *relative* terms.  lynn & vanhanen’s book gives 84 as the IQ of fijian indians.  about the same as native fijians.  don’t ignore the possibility of a lot of substructure in the south asian population along any given vector....

Posted by razib on Sunday, January 2, 2005 at 06:40 AM | #


Razib
I have been into several Fijian Indian homes in my travels and, as you rightly say, their prosperity is relative.  The homes concerned were overcrowded shacks by western standards.  And outside Suva, the cities are very much like Indian ones.  It does seem that expatriate Indians are decidedly limited by the population they live among—which is not surprising.  But just about 100% of Fiji’s businessmen and professionals are Indians.

Posted by John Ray on Sunday, January 2, 2005 at 09:49 AM | #


Another point:  Indians are even the farmers in Fiji and farming (sugar) is still their major industry.  So they are unusually rural for expat Indians.  All the Fijians (Melanesians) do is catch fish, tend gardens and “work” for the government.  Both groups are thoroughly pleasant people though.

Posted by John Ray on Sunday, January 2, 2005 at 09:53 AM | #


Richard Lynn two books:

1.  “IQ and Wealth of Nations:

2 “IQ and Global Inequality”

These two books have good discussions of issue.

With whites centered at 100 (one hundred).

Most of the world can be divided in five group.s

Jews @ 113 IQ.  Al Einstein and others.

East Asians @ 105 IQ

Euro-Whites @ 100 IQ

US blacks, Hispaics, Filipinos, Mexicans @ 85 IQ

Indians in India @ 80-83 IQ

Black Africans in Africa @ 70 IQ

Australian Aborinines @ 60 IQ

It’s the Truth. from over a 100 years of testing and data gathering.

Posted by josh on Monday, July 9, 2007 at 08:59 PM | #


I doubt if the East Indian IQ is 85-80.

I will rate them next to Jews, soewhere around 107-100

reasons:

1. Most of the mathematics which we study today came from the Indians.

2. Indus valley civilization was far more advanced and superior to any other civilization in the world.

3. Have you heard about any east asian winning a nobel prize for breakthrough???

4. Indians have till now won Nobel Prize for breakthroughs

5. J.C. Bose was the real invebtor of Radio proved by the IEEE.

6. Most of the Doctors in US and UK are Indians and Doctors have an IQ somewhere around 100 else they cannot study medicine in the first place.

7. Often I have seen the IQ tests and results are racially biased!

thanks

Irwin , Moscow

Posted by Irwin on Monday, August 20, 2007 at 06:23 PM | #


Thank you, Professor Irwin Corey.  Superior wisdom, from a superior mind.

Posted by James Bowery on Monday, August 20, 2007 at 08:44 PM | #


Jews @ 113 IQ. 
Al Einstein, Edward Teller, J Robert Oppenheimer, etc. 5 of the 10 Richest Americans are Jews.  How come?  How could 2% win 40% of the Nobel Prizes?

East Asians @ 105-108 IQ

Euro-Whites @ 100 IQ

US blacks, Hispanics, Filipinos, Mexicans @ 85 IQ

Indians in India @ 80-83 IQ

Black Africans in Africa @ 70 IQ

Australian Aborinines @ 60 IQ

It’s the Truth. from over a 100 years of testing and data gathering.

These numbers are absoulutely True and correct.

Ask yourself a simple question.  How did present day India, Pakistan, Bangledash and Burma be part of the British Empire until 1947? 

How did the UK flag get to be on the flag of Australia and New Zealand?  How did Africa get colonized from Egypt to South Africa?  How did tiny UK conquer 1/4 of Earth land-space. 

How did 800 Spaniards conquered a million Aztecs in present-day Mexico. How did English and English, from two small nations get to be the world’s language. 

It all about the Truth.  Do not fear th Truth.  Let’s accept and embrace the Truth.
It all goes back to IQ (intelligence)

Posted by josh on Monday, October 8, 2007 at 11:20 PM | #


“Often I have seen the IQ tests and results are racially biased!”

This is a put-on, right?

Posted by Oliver Cromwell on Monday, October 8, 2007 at 11:48 PM | #


Irwin mentions there being a lot of Indian docs in the UK - true.

Dentists are far more likely to be white or Jewish, but far less non-whites are to be seen plying this trade.

Vets are always white, Ive never seen a non-white vet in the UK. Not always Brits but always Euro/White.

I mention these trades as I assume their entry requirements are not that dissimilar to docs.

Im sure there is a story waiting to be told here but Im not quite sure what it is exactly.

It could be significant that most docs are wholly or partly employed by the state (in the UK) whereas most dentists are private. And of course vets are a wholly private concern.

Posted by Lurker on Tuesday, October 9, 2007 at 01:00 AM | #


<<<Indians in India @ 80-83 IQ

Black Africans in Africa @ 70 IQ

Australian Aborinines @ 60 IQ

It’s the Truth. from over a 100 years of testing and data gathering.

These numbers are absoulutely True and correct.

Ask yourself a simple question.  How did present day India, Pakistan, Bangledash and Burma be part of the British Empire until 1947? 
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Sigh! Stats make the truth for this individual, when we all know how limited these studies are.  It is EASY to prove you wrong, Josh:

Fact #1: The Chinese empire was also brought down by the numerically smaller British, yet the IQ for Chinese is 100 (mean IQ), the same as whites. And some suggest their brains are larger (1400+ CC). 

The Japanese also badly lost to the Americans in WW2 despite surprise attacks and a militaristic culture (& govt.)....yet the Japanese have a HIGHER mean IQ than whites. (And no, it was not the nuclear bomb made by brilliant Jews that did the trick, it only hastened the surrender...)

Fact #2: In India, Indians were largely a divided people. It is not one nation, but several joined by political will. The British used a divide/conquer tactic UNTIL the Indians unified under the INC ( a political aegis) and the Muslim League to win political concessions leading to freeness.

Fact #3: There are over 40,000 castes and thousands of genetic pools due to castism, where people married within their own race and types for centuries. So there is NO one genetic racial pool.

Fact #4: In the UK, a researcher by the name of Lin found the mean IO of Indians to be around 97, which is a stone’s throw away from whites (IQ 100). SEE Fact #3 for the reason why, plus add environmental factors—also available in sophisticated urban regions in India like Bombay, Delhi, Calcutta, Bangalore, Madras, etc.

Fact #5: Bangalore is the hub of research investment in India, along with Hyderabad and other places. Several Western companies invest in R&D;in India for engineering, software production, and bio-technlogy. This implies that the thousands of engineers, etc, represent an IQ of 115 or greater in urban regions, SEE Fact #4 to indicate the reason why Indians can compete with whites in IQ.

Given the Bell Curve deviation, that means that an IQ of ~110 can be achieved by 10% or more the group.  More than 50 MILLION Indians live in Urban India, which makes a large number of them (several millions) probably quite competitive with whites, within 3 IQ points.

And this curve is actually erroneous, particularly amongst Indians due to the thousands of genetic pools caused by race intermixing and castes. So the intelligence levels can vary wildly.

As a FYI, to validate my points with hard stats:

FYI#1:
I am an Indian, my tested IQ is 130. I have two university degrees from the United States. So much for “mean IQ” - it is NOT applicable for complex racial mixes like Indians. I gave the reason in Fact #3.

FYI#2:
My friends (Indians of brown as well as wheat complexion) tested in the range of 120-136. One of them is a highly successful engineer (just think of the math used in that subject) with a Masters degree from the US - something impossible at at 80-90 IQ level.

FYI#3:
Amongst Africans (Negro race), Caribbean blacks have studied at higher levels of education than whites in percentage (%) terms by a HUGE margin. So....there are thousands of gene pools in Africa and elsewhere as well, which is why some blacks graduate from college - not possible with a 70-80 IQ range. The IQ level would have to boost to closer to 100-110 for the feat.

Your truth needs a lot of correcting, Josh. Almost all my classmates at school got a Master’s degree from the USA, indicating an IQ capacity of 110-120. Almost all my roomates in Dekalb, Illinois, were Indians in engineering programs at the grad level (so IQ ought to be 110+), which is highly math oriented.

Presently there are over 70,000 Indians who came from India to the US for studies, most at the graduate level - and largely in technology coursework involving math and hard science. They need to pass tough exams like GRE (a full math & logic exam lasting several hours), GMAT for business students (which I did myself, and it is long work), and English tests (TOEFL etc).

All this is NOT possible with an 80-90 IQ. Kapish?

Posted by Shiv on Sunday, October 14, 2007 at 02:10 AM | #


Indians are not,on average, smart.

http://www.vdare.com/rushton/070926_indians.htm

Posted by Al Ross on Sunday, October 14, 2007 at 03:45 AM | #


1.  What is the Truth?

2.  What we wish the Truth to be?

James D. Watson tells the Truth.
Just because we wished does not make Trut.
All we have to do is look at the Native poplulation of the world.

Google the Native populatio the world.

Jews @ 113 IQ

East Asians in china, korea, japan @ 105 + IQ

Euro -Whites in Europe, North America, australia @ 100 IQ

u.s. blacks, mexicans, philipinos @ 85 IQ

India @ 82 IQ

Africa @ 70.

Australian Aborigines @ 60 IQ

China @ 105, Europe @ 100 IQ India @ 82.

Just because we want people to be smart does Not make them smart.
Just becasue I want to win the lottery does Not make me win the lottery next wee.
An individual IQ is meaningless.  You got to test 500, 5000 or 10000 to get a True IQ number for the population

Read
1.  IQ and Wealth of Nations
2.  IQ and Global Inequality

Tatu Vanhanen is the father of the Prime Minister of Finland.  Not a comic book, fantay book.  The books is about the search for Truth.

There is a big difference between

1.  What we wish the world to be.
2.  What is the Real truth about the real-world

Posted by josh stein on Thursday, October 25, 2007 at 07:13 PM | #


You cannot generalize Indian IQ as it varies tremendously amongst various sub population.  Rushton and others disregard the high IQ results by Indian in the US (Hindus have the highest SAT scores as a subgroup) by claiming that this is because of selective immigration, and then take other results of lower IQ by indian immigrants as gospel, which is also a selective group.

There are two types of immigrant from India.  Initially Highly skilled Indians emmigrated to the US. This was the initial wave.  Then their spouses and other relatives also emmigrated. This subset was not as intellectually gifted.  Then there are the economic immigrants.  These are typically people who are not doing too well in India.  Part of the reason is that they could not compete in India. This is the labor class, and probably has low IQ.  This is what is found in Fiji, Vancouver, Gulf, and Carribean.  You cannot make generalization by just looking at one group.

Britain probably has the most representative sample of immigrants. It has the doctors and engineers, along with the lower economic class people.  IQ tests have shown that Indians in Britain have an IQ of 97, despite having a verbal disadvantage of not speaking English in majority of homes.  Another study has indicated that as a group, Hindus do better than white english school children.

Most of the population in India is rural, and their brain does not get the stimulation that is needed to do well on these IQ tests.  However if you question them in their area of expertise, they have good grasp of nuances in agriculture engineering that is needed to be a succesful farmer, rural businessmen, street vendor etc.  There is also a subsection of population that is regressive and dumb, and they tend to belong to the tribal and/or lower caste population.

I would say that there is a population of 300 million in India with IQ comparable with that of white america. This essentially represents the so called middle class in India .  Then there is another 700 million with an average IQ of about 92 (adjusting for what can be termed as Flynn effect).  I would estimate that the average IQ of India is around 94…

Posted by Vic on Thursday, November 1, 2007 at 02:48 PM | #


If I were betting on it I would say , if they were raised in stimulating environment, that there IQ is close to white mean of 100.

I would also bet that they have behavioural differences that make them lazier(work ethic) and are less altruistic that Europeans causing them to have an underdeveloped third world infrastructure.

Posted by voice on Thursday, November 1, 2007 at 03:08 PM | #


I am a professor , I teach math at the university level. I wonder how many of the people on this forum interact in any setting that enables observation of any intelligent traits across the genetic divide. As an educator I do this daily and for as long as I have been running a classroom I have never had an Indian student fail my class. I can however count about a dozen east Asians and score fulls of Caucasians who did not make the grade. On the contrary I have had Indian kids top my class every other year. Also, my general observation has been that Indian students grasp concepts rather quickly and have much better problem solving skills. I for one cannot believe that the Indian IQ is lower than even the American mean. The guys who did the survey got something horribly wrong, these Indians are smart, very smart.
Gordon
Austin, TX

Posted by Gordon on Saturday, February 16, 2008 at 10:23 AM | #


I have difficulty believing Gordon’s letter, which reveals an ignorance of the most basic statistical notions assumed in discussions such as these, was written by a university-level math teacher.  It would be astounding if it were, and this teacher must in such a case be incompetent.  Therefore I doubt the writer is being truthful.  Now, there’s also something unsatisfactory about the prose style of this letter, an awkwardness of a certain sort — not to mention this glaring gaffe, “score fulls of Caucasians” where of course a native English-speaker would’ve said “scores of Caucasians” — that makes me suspect Gordon is foreign, not a native speaker.  I’d guess he’s a Subcon, perhaps attending college in the States although his lack of the most elementary notions of statistical reasoning would be surprising in a college student.  He’s certainly no math major, a flat-out impossibility for that reason.

Posted by Fred Scrooby on Saturday, February 16, 2008 at 01:43 PM | #


Gordon,

IQ notwithstanding; Could it possibly be it’s the West’s degenerate pop-culture that is at the root of the problem? I beleive that is exactly what’s causing Whites from achieving their full academic potential! You see, Whites in this day and age, in general, are preoccupied with entertainment and self indulgence. Conversely, Indians and East Asians take much better advantage of their educational opportunities. One only has to observe the study habits of the different races as it relates to their culture; ie, Blacks leave the study hall/library after an hour, Whites after 2 or 3 hours, while Asians are there 6 or 7 hours—ditto for the Jews. That’s the reason for the achievement gap. It’s that simple.

Posted by onlooker on Saturday, February 16, 2008 at 02:57 PM | #


Gordon is an Indian name. Like a typical Indian, Gordon lies and twists to brag how bright Indians are. I have been working in India for past 15 years and witness myself how primitive, filthy and low IQ an average India is. For one thing, Indian normally use bare hands for food without washing. I am not talking about bread. They rake for food in soup with their bare hands. They also do not use toilet paper! They use their bare hands too for wiping their a$$! If you see a basin of water in front of an India toilet, stay away!

Posted by nicknguyen on Monday, February 18, 2008 at 07:46 AM | #


To the Stupid Poster Irwin,Moscow who said East Asians have never won a Nobel Prize,Actually there are HEAPS of East Asians that have won a Nobel Prize before.
There have been 7 ‘Chinese Nobel Prize Winners’,they are Steven Chu (physics), Samuel C. C. Ting (physics), Chen Ning Yang (physics), Tsung-Dao Lee (physics), Yuan T. Lee (chemistry), Daniel C. Tsui(physics), Gao Xingjian(literature), Fields Medal (Maths Equivalent of Nobel Prize) recipients Terence Tao and Shing-Tung Yau, and Turing Award (Computer Science Equivalent of Nobel Prize) recipient Andrew Yao. Other significant Chinese scientists who never won a Nobel Prize include Tsien Hsue-shen whom was a prominent scientist at NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory, while Chien-Shiung Wu contributed to the Manhattan Project. Others include Charles K. Kao, a pioneer in fiber optics technology, and Doctor David Ho, one of the first scientists to propose that AIDS was caused by a virus, thus subsequently developing combination antiretroviral therapy to combat it. Dr. Ho was named TIME magazine’s 1996 Man of the Year.

There are also heaps of Japanese Nobel Prize Winners, they include:
Masatoshi Koshiba, Physics, 2002
Koichi Tanaka, Chemistry, 2002
Ryoji Noyori, Chemistry, 2001
Hideki Shirakawa, Chemistry, 2000
Kenzaburo Oe, Literature, 1994
Susumu Tonegawa*, Physiology or Medicine, 1987
Kenichi Fukui, Chemistry, 1981
Eisaku Sato, Peace, 1974
Leo Esaki, Physics, 1973
Yasunari Kawabata, Literature, 1968
Shinichirou Tomonaga, Physics, 1965
Hideki Yukawa, Physics, 1949

There are many other great Japanese scientists who never won Nobel Prize but made medical breakthroughs.For example,DNA Replication ‘Okazaki Fragments’ was discovered by Japanese medical scientists Reiji Okazaki, Tsuneko Okazaki.
Others include Noguchi Hideyo,a Japanese Bacteriologist who discovered the agent that caused Syphilus.Other medical breakthroughs like Bleomycin (anti-cancer drug) were also made by Japanese.

Koreans have also won a Nobel Prize before.Kim Dae Jung won a Nobel Prize for Korea in 2000.

The ancient Chinese were the greatest inventors ‘the four great inventions of ancient China’-Gunpowder,Paper,Printing and Compass were all invented by Chinese.This is all written in history books and was even on the ‘DISCOVERY CHANNEL’.Other ‘ancient Chinese’ inventions include:seismological detectors, matches, paper, cannon, flare, continuous flame throwers, fire arrow, paper-printed money, chain drive, escapement, pendulum, silk, multistage rocket, landmine, quilling-wheel, odometer, sluice gate, the canal lock, flash lock, rudder, pontoon bridge, water-tight compartment, blast furnace, porcelain, belt drive, dry docks, sliding calipers, the double-action piston pump, cast iron, metal stirrups, civil service examination system, paddle wheels, the iron plow, the multi-tube seed drill, the wheelbarrow, rotary winnowing fan, collapsible umbrella, toothbrush, trip hammer, trebuchet, kites, Su Song water-driven astronomical clock tower, grand canal, horse collar, chain pump, pound lock, the suspension bridge, the parachute, natural gas as fuel, the magnetic compass, the raised-relief map, the propeller, innoculation, the crossbow etc.

So please don’t make stupid statements about East Asians inventing nothing or winning no Nobel Prizes without doing your research first,and read some history please.

Posted by East Asian on Thursday, February 28, 2008 at 05:11 AM | #


1.  Nobel prizes.  All east asians of chinese descent have won their Nobel Prizes while working in USA-based universities.

True.  they did win their Nobel prize, but not working in china.

2. The barbaric Imperial exams stunted science for hundreds. Rote-memorization of confucius stunted all creativity. 

Confucius made china-chinese into mindless-zombie idiots. goole confucius, imperial exams. 

Imperial government was abolished in 1911.

1911-2011, 100 years without a backward, primative government.

3.  china has Hanzi- primative, barbarcic writing system invented by the devil himself.  3000-4000 characters just to read the newsapapers.  what about an alphabet. 

abcdefghijklmnipqrstuvwxyz.  goole alphabet

The whole earth is now using a alphabet-based system.

or numbers 0123456789

4.  Now in the age of science-tech, google, yahoo, 21st. century flat-world, digital-world. we all know the truth.

5.  Before 1945, world war II, japanese and germans can send army to invade another. Nations. Japan bombed pearl harbor.  usa dropped two atomic bombs on japan. 

Hiroshima obsoleted invasion by large armies.  There will be economic competition, tech, cultural competition among nations, among companies, among individuals, but there will be invasions by the japanese or germans.

6. Once china terminates, kills confucius, Hanzi, crap-zi, boy-emperor, foot-binding, religion, all of the ugly, primative, feudal past.  and ccp (kommunist party), china will be a great nation again.

Posted by charles lee on Saturday, March 1, 2008 at 07:58 PM | #


nicknguyen, do you believe it is right to despise an entire group of people because they were born in India?  No on chooses what they are, and yet you call them “filthy” because of something they cannot control?  And you believe this is right?  You are part of the lowest rung of humankind, and you still succumb to your primitive instincts of xenophobia.

Posted by Berthold Friedmann on Saturday, March 1, 2008 at 11:16 PM | #


Nguyen is a vietnamese name, they are the dirtiest shithole on earth, they smell of shit and seafood, they represents the poorest people in the western world. I have not seen them using any toilet paper either, becuse they eat shit. They eat raw seafood and crawling reptiles still very primitive. Chinese, vietnamese, malaysians, koreans, all come from third world countries, their claim to higher intelligence is hallucinatory and come out of inferiority complex, they are more closely related to Orungutans a primate just like Africans are closely related to chimpanzees and gorillas.
Nguyen should have to see and Orangutan to see the reflection of his face, he would never resent looking to the mirror instead. Also these east Asians are characterised by smallest of penis on the planet, all Chinese girls run towards westerners, Middle eastern and Indians to get sexual satisfaction, leaving there male Orangutans.

By the way there are Four Billionare Indians in the top 10 Billionaires in the world and not a single orangutan (east Asian) so you can see yourself who has the higher IQ!!

Posted by Him on Saturday, March 8, 2008 at 08:29 AM | #


So you are an Indian.  Do you think that kind of language reflects well on your personal and national character?  Do you think readers will sympathise with your point of view, or consider you self-evidently aloof from the “shit-eating orangutang” that you draw for us? 

Frankly, I am amazed that anyone so bereft of normal sensibility considers himself competent to offer an opinion on anyone or anything.  Have you never heard the famous bon mot about discretion and valour?  Aware of your profound limitations you should be choosing discretion, believe me.

No go, and do not besmirch our proceedings again.  I shall not object too strongly if you take Mr Nguyen with you.

Posted by Guessedworker on Saturday, March 8, 2008 at 01:20 PM | #


India is the world’s largest, oldest, continuous civilization.
India never invaded any country in her last 10000 years of history.
India is the world’s largest democracy.
Varanasi, also known as Benares, was called “the ancient city” when Lord Buddha visited it in 500 B.C.E, and is the oldest, continuously inhabited city in the world today.
India invented the Number System. Zero was invented by Aryabhatta.
The World’s first university was established in Takshashila in 700BC. More than 10,500 students from all over the world studied more than 60 subjects. The University of Nalanda built in the 4th century BC was one of the greatest achievements of ancient India in the field of education.
Sanskrit is the mother of all the European languages. Sanskrit is the most suitable language for computer software - a report in Forbes magazine, July 1987.
Ayurveda is the earliest school of medicine known to humans. Charaka, the father of medicine consolidated Ayurveda 2500 years ago. Today Ayurveda is fast regaining its rightful place in our civilization.
Although modern images of India often show poverty and lack of development, India was the richest country on earth until the time of British invasion in the early 17th Century. Christopher Columbus was attracted by India’s wealth.
The art of Navigation was bornin the river Sindhu 6000 years ago. The very word Navigation is derived from the Sanskrit word NAVGATIH. The word navy is also derived from Sanskrit ‘Nou’.
Bhaskaracharya calculated the time taken by the earth to orbit the sun hundreds of years before the astronomer Smart. Time taken by earth to orbit the sun: (5th century) 365.258756484 days.
The value of pi was first calculated by Budhayana, and he explained the concept of what is known as the Pythagorean Theorem. He discovered this in the 6th century long before the European mathematicians.
Algebra, trigonometry and calculus came from India. Quadratic equations were by Sridharacharya in the 11th century. The largest numbers the Greeks and the Romans used were 106 whereas Hindus used numbers as big as 10**53(10 to the power of 53) with specific names as early as 5000 BCE during the Vedic period. Even today, the largest used number is Tera 10**12(10 to the power of 12).
IEEE has proved what has been a century old suspicion in the world scientific community that the pioneer of wireless communication was Prof. Jagdish Bose and not Marconi.
The earliest reservoir and dam for irrigation was built in Saurashtra.
According to Saka King Rudradaman I of 150 CE a beautiful lake called Sudarshana was constructed on the hills of Raivataka during Chandragupta Maurya’s time.
Chess (Shataranja or AshtaPada) was invented in India.
Sushruta is the father of surgery. 2600 years ago he and health scientists of his time conducted complicated surgeries like cesareans, cataract, artificial limbs, fractures, urinary stones and even plastic surgery and brain surgery. Usage of anesthesia was well known in ancient India. Over 125 surgical equipment were used. Deep knowledge of anatomy, physiology, etiology, embryology, digestion, metabolism, genetics and immunity is also found in many texts.
When many cultures (Anglo Saxons, Germans, French) were only nomadic forest dwellers over 5000 years ago, Indians established Harappan culture in Sindhu Valley (Indus Valley Civilization).
The four religions born in India, Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, and Sikhism, are followed by 25% of the world’s population.
The place value system, the decimal system was developed in India in 100 BC.
India is one of the few countries in the World, which gained independence without violence.
India has the second largest pool of Scientists and Engineers in the World.
India is the largest English speaking nation in the world.
India is the only country other than US and Japan, to have built a super computer indigenously.
In 2008 India currently has 4 dollar Billionaires in the top ten super rich Forbes billionaire list more than United States or any other country in the world.

The IQ scores are not the benchmark in the determining the national IQ, the result can be manipulated and altered to give certain countries a significant advantage over others, especially in the western world which suffers from skin colour bias. These IQ scores can be used to reject people with dark skin in preference to light skin by assuming that they are of lower IQ. Chinese are light skin and are more acceptable to white men especially the chinese girls which are softer target for western males because of their stronger tilt towards multiple sexual partners. These IQ scores are nothing but a form of scientific racism, a old wine in a new bottle, to practice racism with a reason and even get a legal recognition for their evil deeds. You go and check the IQ score of a rural poor who are illiterate and malnourished and brand whole country as of lower IQ is nothing but a consiparacy by the racist west. The literacy rates in rural India are much lower than literacy rates in rural China, that can possibly explain the low IQ scores. The IQ scores are more relevant in the countries where there is less social divide between the socio-economic condition of the urban middle class and rural populace.

Posted by Raja on Saturday, March 8, 2008 at 11:28 PM | #


A very large number of sources seem to believe that the words navy & navigation are derived from the Greek word ‘navis’. (How silly of them to think that when Greece is only part of Europe and we all know how those inventive Indian mariners circumnavigated the globe and discovered Europe.)

If you want to drop an e-mail to the (thousands) of websites propagating this myth I’ll be more than happy to post a list.

I note that almost all the (hundreds) of sites that forward the sanskrit origin of navigation use exactly the same wording as you:

“The very word Navigation is derived from the Sanskrit word NAVGATIH.” Though to be fair some of them drop the word ‘very’, so I contend that in this case you are merely parroting Indian propaganda.

Regarding Bose and Marconi - and not to downplay Bose in other respects - to demonstrate Bose’s pre-eminence as a pioneer you need to prove that he not only did things first but that Marcon’is work derived from his.

Posted by Lurker on Sunday, March 9, 2008 at 03:59 AM | #


Him,

East Asians never said they were the most intelligent race and the most highly evolved race in the world.It was Western European Anthropologists and Scientists who said that,so please complain to these western european scientists instead of yelling insults atEast Asians for something they never wrote.

Books that claim east asian intelligence and evolutionary superiority were all written by Europeans:

“IQ and the Wealth of Nations 2002” is written Dr. Richard Lynn, Professor Emeritus of Psychology at the University of Ulster, Northern Ireland, and Dr. Tatu Vanhanen, Professor Emeritus of Political Science at the University of Tampere, Tampere, Finland.

“IQ and Global Inequality” 2006 was written by Dr. Richard Lynn, Professor Emeritus of Psychology at the University of Ulster, Northern Ireland, and Dr. Tatu Vanhanen, Professor Emeritus of Political Science at the University of Tampere, Tampere, Finland.

“Race, Evolution, and Behavior: A Life History Perspective (3rd Edition)”
by J. Philippe Rushton.

You are extremely ignorant to state that ‘Chinese and Koreans’ live in ‘Third World’ Countries.It only shows your lack of intelligence.Perhaps you should read a book or even wikipedia,before making such outrageous claims.

‘Chinese’ countries like Taiwan(Republic of China),Singapore and Hong Kong are ‘First World Nations’ ‘Industrialised Developed Country’.
South Korea is also a first-world Nation, ‘Industrialised Advanced Economy’.

The ‘Four Asian Tigers’ (the only developed countries in Asian Continent outside Japan) are all East Asian countries- South Korea,Singapore,Taiwan and Hong Kong.Perhaps you should read up on the ‘Four Asian Tigers’.

Vietnamese are not East Asians,they are South East Asians.Do you even know the difference? East Asians are Han Chinese,Japanese and Korean only.

And no,East Asians do not run to White,Middle Eastern or Indian men for ‘so-called’ satisfaction.As an East Woman myself,I can honestly say 95% of East Asian woman strictly go for East Asian Men.The East Asian woman who date non-East Asian men are either (1)Not desirable among East Asian men hence are forced to look elsewhere for a partner, or (2)Grew up in a Western country and a have a Western mindset (3) Hookers

Posted by To 'Him' on Saturday, March 22, 2008 at 02:42 AM | #


They say that East Asians have larger brains.

If you say that Chinese have poor scores here in US, you are lying. Most of our children here are excellent academically. If you look into the student bodies at University of California campuses or most of very good pre-college schools in California, you should know that. I would imagine that the situation in Texas is the same for Texas’ Chinese populations (for they are almost all from more recent immigrants unlike California).

Posted by Chinese on Tuesday, March 25, 2008 at 05:37 PM | #


IQ test (like any other test) results have a lot to do with how the tested subject is programmed academically and culturally. A more educated person should have a better result.

They should do some research on separated twins at very young ages.

For curiosity, I had rushed through an IQ test before. I got 135. On a different day and a different test, I could get a much better or worse score. Intelligence is very hard to measure. Any measurement has limitations.

Posted by Chinese on Tuesday, March 25, 2008 at 06:12 PM | #


I just read this:

http://www.news-medical.net/?id=9530

I would have to take a deeper look at it.

Posted by Chinese on Tuesday, March 25, 2008 at 09:57 PM | #


For curiosity, I had rushed through an IQ test before. I got 135.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=04QoA44c23A

Posted by onlooker on Tuesday, March 25, 2008 at 10:36 PM | #


Indo-Aryans are the most spiritually evolved race in the world, the Rig veda, Puranas and the Geeta the ancient Indian texts which has shunned material existence of human kind in preference to the purification of soul and good Karma can’t be wrong. The low life western scum only lay emphasis on material wealth and waste their lives in over indulgence in SEX, DRUGS, AlCOHOL and Worldly Pleasures suffer from plethora of social problems, thats why they are mimicking animals. The most Obese and mentally ill nations in the world are in the west viz US, UK, Australia, still trying to generalise that other races stinks!!.

Today’s world is suffering from various challenges which is casting a doubt on the long term viability of life on the planet Earth are created by western low life capitalist and scum bags who call themselves superior and of Higher IQ. The food and grain shortages, melting of glaciers, climate change, green house effect, extiction of wild life and faunal species, deforestation, population explosion, pollution of air and groundwater, dieing oceans and river systems, tonnes of waste generation, are the result of western greed for more wealth and it appears they have infected the whole world with this infectious disease of lust for pleasure and wealth- we are aproaching doomsday due to duffer and racists like Dr. Richard Lynn and Dr Vanhanen who are tryinng to make their living on absurd theories which has no substance. I bet these racist bastards have IQ lower than a Pig.

Posted by Him on Monday, March 31, 2008 at 11:11 AM | #


If you had been to India, had lived among Indians, and witnessed masses of the physically weak, mentally slow and disease ridden Indians in Slumbai, Bangalore, Madras, and Calcutta, you would have known that India will be the biggest liability of the earth. India has largest number of Aids infected, an ever increasing population, badly polluted environment, and depleted resources. With her government too incompetent to reverse these adversaries, India is a disaster in the making. It is NOT the low IQ that will doom India stupid! It is the Indian explosive breed like rabbit. If you were an Indian patriot, you should stop all these delusional ego-kissing hype and go back to the basics of growth control of India population!

Posted by reality bites on Saturday, April 5, 2008 at 07:50 AM | #


No amount of racism and negative popoganda can stop Indians to accomplish what they want already they are the most successful ethinc group in the west. The richest man in European Union is LN Mittal worth USD 45 Billion, CEO of Arcelor Mittal the largest steel company in the world. Indian Americans are one of the most successful ethnic group in the US with average household income worth USD 60,000, over 2 million of them are more successful on an average than whites, it is not by accident but due to strong influence of vedic culture and higher level of intelligence. Indians are as successful as East Asians or Jews in the US and UK this proves that Indians enjoy higher level of intelligence contrary to what some racist says. I can also say that Americans are the dumbest people on earth who spent 3 trillion dollars on fighting an imaginary enemy in Iraq and Afghanistan and now they are facing economic recession and poverty with million of jobs axed and 36 million on food assistance due to poverty. And that is some what true after all which country on earth will let their people starve to search for WMD which doesn’t exist.

India will be a superpower in 20 years’
17 Jan 2004, 0209 hrs IST, D Chaware,TNN

When Jeffrey Armstrong predicted over 20 years ago that Silicon Valley would be overrun by Indian innovators and engineers, no one believed him. Today, his prophecy has come true manifold.  I based my forecast on the fact that Indians have a very strong Sanskrit background, he says. Sanskrit being the perfect language for computer programming, I was confident even then that Indians would outshine others in computer innovations.

His next prediction is equally interesting: India will become a superpower in another 20 years, even earlier if Indians propagate their culture and legacy effectively in the West. The motivational speaker, who left his corporate job seven years ago to foster the spread of Hindu and Vedic culture in the West, looks like a typical American till he opens his mouth. The barrage of Sanskrit shlokas, names of ancient rishis and quotes from Indian philosophers that emerges thereafter, however, could give any desi a complex. Lauding Indian contributions to the world of science and the arts, the incorrigible Indophile rues the fact that Indians abroad are not networked. It’s also unfortunate that there is no systematic plan to reach out to the millions of non-Indian people in the West who love, respect and follow Indian traditions like yoga and vegetarianism in their daily life, he says. Currently on a tour of India, the Armstrongs are now settled in Canada.

Maintaining that India is already becoming an intellectual leader of the world, Mr Armstrong says that even ayurveda is fast picking up in the West. “In the US alone, over half a dozen universities have been approached to recognise ayurveda as a complimentary therapy and I am hopeful that within a couple of years, this branch of medicine will be as popular as other Indian therapies like yoga and transcendental meditation,’’ he says, adding that the National Ayurvedic Medicine Association (NAMA) has already been set up in Canada and the US to promote the cause. To bolster his prediction about Indians becoming leaders of the world in the near future, Mr Armstrong declares that the maximum outsourcing for the West is now from India. In almost every sphere of activity, Indians are the frontrunners,’’ he says. “Most of the prominent scientists, doctors, technocrats and innovators are Indians.’’ The couple, which has founded an educational institute called the Vedic Academy of Science and Arts (VASA), is now working on creating a permanent library of Hindu and Vedic culture in Vancouver. Their clients include successful businessmen, lawyers, corporate executives and leaders of society. “Bring as much knowledge from India as you can,’’ concludes Mr Armstrong. “People in north America are eager for it.’’

Posted by Him on Monday, April 7, 2008 at 09:38 AM | #


Although some of the data is a little old, this link shows rankings in several categories by ethnicity (complied by Arthur Hu).

http://www.arthurhu.com/INDEX/overrep.htm

Posted by VM on Thursday, April 10, 2008 at 04:46 PM | #


so you can see yourself who has the higher IQ!!

Yes, you have robber barons living in the UK while millions of Indians starve.

Posted by asdfasdfasdf on Wednesday, April 23, 2008 at 01:45 AM | #


When u discuss India, it is unfair to lump extremely diversified Indians as a single race especially when u cover the topic of average IQ. In addition, India is governed by hundreds of thousands of castes and sub-cultures. We have some very intelligent castes in the North and also have some low IQ castes in the South. Indians comprise of many different racial and genetic traits because of her histories. India was once conquered by Arabian. The Arabians mixed with local women and left behind the religion and genie pool. Turkey also conquered India and forced with locals and again left its genetic trails. Persians also invaded India and mixed with local women and had their decedents in India. So did Afghanistan. Even Mongols conquered India and mixed with local women. Now, India has oriental looking Indians. Only Aryans invading did not force issues with local women and maintained the different genetic traits.

In short, u have to differentiate highly intelligent high caste Northern like Northern Brahmins from low IQ southern low caste Dravidians. However, I do worry that lowly southern Dravidians outbreed Northern high castes and will further bring down India average IQ.

Posted by RJ on Thursday, May 1, 2008 at 04:01 PM | #


India consists of the following disparate and genetically separate populations

Brahmins , 5%, 125 IQ
Other Upper Castes, 15%, 110 IQ
Other Backward Castes, 40%, 95 IQ
Muslims, 15%, 85 IQ
SC/ST, 25%, 80 IQ

Averaging this will give a composite IQ of 93

The above is for the section of population that is well fed
and well schooled

In India, Malnutrition is 55% as against 10% in china
and Womens illiteracy is 50% as against 10% in china

and this would drop IQ about 10 points from what it will eventually be

In addition, the chinese IQ tests were done in Beijing and Shanghai
The Indian IQ tests were done not in Delhi and Bangalore, but in
Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, and Orissa, which are the poorest,
most illiterate and malnourished and backward places
The caste composition of the Indian testees is not known
For example Orissa consists of 50% SC/ST

I shall test my hypothesis

Indians in Fiji were recruited as contract laborers and the british wanted a docile and illiterate
population that could be exploited
The Indians in Fiji are 50% Backward Caste , 95 IQ and 50% SC/ST with 80 iQ
An average gives an Average Fiji IQ of 87, The test scores is 84 IQ
If this group had a western society they would score 87
In Fiji, the native Fijians have 84 IQ
95% of Fiji professionals are Indians , I would expect that these are
from the backward castes, 95 IQ

Posted by rec1man on Thursday, May 15, 2008 at 01:19 AM | #


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indian_mathematics

Fields of Indian mathematics
Some of the areas of mathematics studied in ancient and medieval India include the following:

Arithmetic: Decimal system, Negative numbers (see Brahmagupta), Zero (see Hindu-Arabic numeral system), the modern positional notation numeral system, Floating point numbers (see Kerala School), Number theory, Infinity (see Yajur Veda), Transfinite numbers, Irrational numbers (see Sulba Sutras)
Geometry: Square roots (see Bakhshali approximation), Cube roots (see Mahavira), Pythagorean triples (see Sulba Sutras; Baudhayana and Apastamba state the Pythagorean theorem without proof), Transformation (see Panini), Pascal’s triangle (see Pingala)
Algebra: Quadratic equations (see Sulba Sutras, Aryabhata, and Brahmagupta), Cubic equations (see Mahavira and Bhaskara), Quartic equations (biquadratic equations; see Mahavira and Bhaskara)
Mathematical logic: Formal grammars, formal language theory, the Panini-Backus form (see Panini), Recursion (see Panini)
General mathematics: Fibonacci numbers (see Pingala), Earliest forms of Morse code (see Pingala), Logarithms, indices (see Jaina mathematics), Algorithms, Algorism (see Aryabhata and Brahmagupta)
Trigonometry: Trigonometric functions (see Surya Siddhanta and Aryabhata), Trigonometric series (see Madhava and Kerala School)

Posted by rec1man on Thursday, May 15, 2008 at 01:23 AM | #


wow I’m a US mom of two little boys.  they are going to a Chinese immersion elementary school here, since I want them to have a bigger world view (than your typical American) I googled Chinese, language, IQ, to see how they may benefit from our school choice, and got to this site.  I’m not sure I want them to be part of the world community after reading these posts.  I’m pretty sure KINDNESS exists in all your cultures, does it not?  I shun (despise) organized religion, but I love this (bible) statement.  “Much is expected from those to whom much is given, for their responsibility is greater” You all seem so ready to post your IQ; find a greater cause.

Posted by momoftwoboys on Saturday, May 17, 2008 at 02:28 AM | #


Interesting articles on how China is outperforming India on almost every meaningful measure of social and economic progress:

http://en.citizendium.org/wiki/Life_expectancy
http://www.rediff.com/money/2005/sep/27china.htm

I want both India and China to do well. I have never heard a Chinese disparage India’s efforts to improve themselves. But plenty of Indians seem to dislike the Chinese resurgence. I do not want to put India down, but if attacked - hence the articles at the links above. Indians get real. You are going nowhere with that backward, immoral Hindu religion. The Chinese at least had the gumption to get rid of foot-binding, landlordism, and feudal superstitions. This could only have happened under a communist government.

Posted by Wayne1770 on Friday, May 23, 2008 at 10:46 AM | #


To identify myself in this very narrow context I state that I am a 143 IQ Indian. So I lay before you the two parameters on the basis of which you judicious people have so kindly classified entire populations.

The world moves forward towards globalization and you sit behind the cloak of anonymity that the internet offers you , taking snide shots at each others ‘genetic pools’ and ‘races’. Do you guys realize how stupid you sound?

There are smart people, average IQ folks and downright dumb folks in every country and race. Yes the average IQ of one country may exceed that of another. So what? Are you actually that insecure about your heritage and lineage that you need to prove it here?? - Through posts on a site??

Local governance has nothing to do with IQ. And that’s a fact. Countries didn’t colonize other countries because they were ‘smarter’. If they were smart enough they wouldn’t resort to colonization or war in the first place.

Besides what is the big deal about IQ anyways? The test is heavily biased and proves nothing in real life. There are tons of people with astronomical IQs doing absolutely nothing with their life. Yet I know people, who with much lower IQs can create art, music, literary compositions, I could never dream of. Irrespective of their country.

Some of the views thrown about in this forum only prove that the authors have very limited IQs and restricted thinking abilities. Please engage these sparse faculties of yours in something more constructive and refrain from commenting on topics you know nothing about. That will help your country/ race/ gene pool/ football club/poker league alot more. Trust me.

Posted by Rohan on Tuesday, May 27, 2008 at 03:12 PM | #


“The world moves forward towards globalization and you sit behind the cloak of anonymity that the internet offers you , taking snide shots at each others ‘genetic pools’ and ‘races’. Do you guys realize how stupid you sound?”

Anonymity - the good old double standard rears its head. If I as a white person in a white country, the US, Europe etc say I want white people to remain a majority I run the risk of prosecution, accusations of racism, facism, nazism, loss of employment. You as a non-white can pop up in our territory and happily cheer on the day that we will be a minority or even cease to exist, even organize political groups to that end (eg La Raza in the US) and suffer what penalty? Nothing as far as I can see. So you can take your anonymity and shove it.

Internet - the one that our people conceived, designed, built and implemented and now see used by the likes of you.  We’ll do what we like with our internet thanks, you go and start your own from scratch.

“The world moves forward towards globalization”

So, remind me, how is that African immigration into India coming along? After all African labour is even cheaper than Indian, I really cant see what the hold up is. The Indian government wouldnt be so stupid and racist as not allow anyone to settle based on trivialities like race, IQ, culture etc.

“what is the big deal about IQ anyways? The test is heavily biased and proves nothing in real life”

Im glad you mentioned that Mr 143 IQ, it certainly removes the single flimsy justification for us importing you into our territory.

Posted by Lurker on Tuesday, May 27, 2008 at 05:14 PM | #


Wow! Some real eye openers here.. On how people of different communities look at each other. About who is smart, and who is not. About whose internet it is, and whose it is not. About who gave the world the world of mathematics. And finally, about how the lowly South Indian dravidians who are bringing the nation’s(India’s) IQ down. The list is never ending!

I am a south Indian, and probably of dravidian race (lowly, perhaps?). And I am not ashamed about who I am, or from where I come. I would not like to label myself with an IQ, so that you may decide whether to hear me out or not, based on what I write, not by the number which tells me my competence.

Honestly, we Indians have a long way to go. Not with respect to the IQ though. I have traveled extensively in my country and am always amazed by the wisdom that is inherent among the Indians. But, we are not testing wisdom, are we? We are testing intelligence.

IQ tests in the present format, are formal methods aimed at testing the educated people. Unfortunately, thanks to the bungling of the Indian political system, and the lack of awareness among the junta, education in India has a long way to go. So the average Indian is not trained enough, and would certainly not fare well in a formal IQ test. Most Indians who are not in Urban India, would never ever have appeared for an IQ test in their lives. Internet has changed a lot in India. Yeah, yeah.. your internet! smile Maybe, years ago, Indians used to say, “our” mathematics! Or maybe not.

Wayne1770 mentioned about Indians disparaging the chinese resurgence. Well, there would be, because we Indians aren’t growing fast enough, and the Chinese make sure that we are occupied with various issues with our neighbours. Such as the terrorism emanating from Pakistan, to which China exports nuclear capable 3000 km range missile technology; or the drug and mafia circuits through Nepal and Bangladesh; Nepal where the Maoists with the help of the Chinese have taken over the nation, and Bangladesh, to which China gives goodies so that they are anti India. With all these subversive policies against India, wouldn’t you think that Indians would be wary about the Chinese prosperity, which they use to keep the Indian nation down?

Indians have a lot to do to get their political, judicial, social and educational system right. Democracy does not work for a new born nation. Communism, with the power in the hands of the right people- the visionaries works. India embraced democracy, and power fell in the hands of the people who were not capable nor had the inclination of developing the nation. And in democracy, a wise man’s say is as good/bad as that of the unwise. China surged ahead during this time like a start-up running with a corporate structure.

I hope I was able to throw some light on the issues pertaining to India and China, the relationship between them, and most importantly, why the IQ of an average Indian seems lesser compared to the Chinese. Democracy has its own positives and negatives. We have seen the negatives till now, and as the average Indian becomes more educated and aware, the positives of democracy should show up. I have no excuses though, for the relative poor performance of us as a nation in terms of development.

Looking back at this longish post, just proves what we are good at! Talk! smile
Thanks you for your patience. And chill!

Posted by Nitin on Thursday, May 29, 2008 at 08:43 PM | #


Lurker, I did not understand your comments!

First, how does anonymity and the issue of white majority relate? The political organisation is real. They are not anonymous.

Second, Internet. If you so much wish to use only your internet, please do so. Stop using products of Google, Sun, Microsoft, Amazon, Target, Alcatel-Lucent, Motorola, Bell, Texas Instruments etc. ;all those companies whose research and development is done in India. Go back to your internet of 1995. By the way, where do you think the internet was developed? US? grin Check out what CERN is all about. Thanks to those guys for the internet. We are grateful and we will happily use it, irrespective of some lurkers objections.

Third, Globalisation. We have enough number of people in our own country and the competition is too huge for the africans to survive.

Finally, there are enough Indians who DONOT wish to migrate, and so the companies themselves migrate to India. Globalisation is here and it is here to stay!

Posted by Nitin on Thursday, May 29, 2008 at 09:18 PM | #


Here’s a link which may give you some cheer, as far as Indian development is considered..
http://www.rediff.com/money/2008/may/30nile.htm

Posted by Nitin on Friday, May 30, 2008 at 05:12 AM | #


I am an Indian, work in UK.

Indeed Whites or may be Brits have the highest IQ, since they ruled almost every part of the world except Japan.

1. Why did 2 out of 2 world wars fought in Europe?
2. UK is now full of immigrants from 3rd world?
3. I cant find a white doctor in NHS.
4. Why do they need low IQ people like me to work fro them?
5. What is UK’s source of income other than VAT and TAX (I wonder how long the loot will last which they stole from every country they ruled)
6. why is every electrical/electronic product has made in china label and ever garment has been either imported from India / Pak or other Asian (3rd world) countries.
7. why is UK and US Citizens are so scared of immigrants and they worry about their very existence?

Who are Americans? Native Red Indians no longer exist in huge numbers.

Rest were English criminals who were sent to American Land. Australians are they any different from them ?

Indeed Brits have a highest IQ because they know how to divide and rule, and professors of corruption which they have taught to 3rd world. No wonder Indians were their best students.

What does India/ china export products, garments, software and TALK of-course (call centers)?
And what does US Exports Military Hardware ? Thanks to them for introducing a newer form on 21st century imperialism over Fuel.
Do we know any single war in the last 110 years where US was not involved?

Indeed UK and US Nationals have greater IQ than the rest of the world.

Once India was Gold (not golden) sparrow and now what it has become .. thanks to high (very) IQ of Brits grin

Anyone who has paranoia should seek a help of a psychiatrist (Please see a US or UK Born doctor next time), careful of Low IQ-ed Indian Docs.

Posted by vixflix on Saturday, May 31, 2008 at 12:55 AM | #


vixflix I really liked your post! Ya you tell them! smile
Although i disagree with the British being totally responsible for the colonization of India. You have to admit that the “racist” minds of Indians were part of the reason for the British Raj.

Posted by Peter on Saturday, May 31, 2008 at 07:00 PM | #


hi all,, this is an interesting topic........

i am a chinese kid around 18 years old, and my college here got around 50 other overseas chinese kid and about 30-40 indian who are studying A-level currently, the total number of pupil of the whole college is around 300
...
there is a math competition held through the whole nation called “The UK senior math challenge” actually it is kinda iq test

i have been here for 3 years, and every year i looked the top 100 pupils, and i was amazed by the names on the list… around 20-30 pupil are chinese, how come there are so many chinese while the chinese pupil papulation in uk school is about 0.0001%?

by the way, i dont really rely on NHS, simply because there are so many Indian doctors, i am afraid their mis-diagnose..  white doctors are good though, but too few of them

i can see lots of stuffs are made in china here, partly it is due to cheap labor ,secondly it is chinese are more skillful and fast learning.... but where is the inidan thing?

the truth is china is now fully technologically restricted, everything have to do by themselves ...otherwise many europeans will lose their job now....
in contrast, india is fully technologically unrestricted, but why didnt they can make a fully functioned tank?

the only thing that chinese failed is the english language, chinese english is not as good as the indian in our college, partly bacause chinese kids have been learning it for 2 or 3 years, while the indian are born here

India is no match of China, whether you like it or not ,it is the truth,,, please you ppl dont put them together comparing each other.....

china has dominated fields of techology and art before 1600 AD, but surpassed by the british impire about 1800 AD ... THIS IS because the british went industrialisation, while the chinese went central planning and stronger bureaucratism which didnt encourage techology inventions and science developments

anyway, let’s see what china will become in 20-30 years , and india.......
which will prove the IQ theory is true…

my only hopes are there are no wars and earthquakes..................

peace smile

Posted by kid 1 on Sunday, June 1, 2008 at 06:21 PM | #


kid 1 and all who are reading this post.

The point here is not where will China/ India or any other country would stand in next 2 or 3 decades.

Every country has its own problems / limitations and of course there positives and resources which are yet to be exploited.

China is not the only country where earth quakes come, Japan has more number of earth quakes recorded than any other nation, isn’t it?
US suffers from Hurricanes. India has its own set of issues be it Floods, Tsunami, Quakes or Social issues like Corruption, Huge population that too majority is below poverty line compared to the available resources, and Terrorism.

I bet where people are busy in dealing with the basic need of food, shelter and clothing you can not expect them to score 100 or above in IQ test.

FYI: English is spoken only in Cities in India.

From my point of view Human Intelligence will only prove its worth if they do something useful for the planet and for the life form.

I think all of us here arguing on the question of which Country has highest avg IQ, we have proven that we lack The Common Sense.
Their are lot of things and work to be done for the benefit of core life form and of-course humans and this planet.

Posted by vixflix on Tuesday, June 3, 2008 at 01:27 PM | #


Dear author of blog post,

You are indeed correct with your assumption that the IQ score for India is probably incorrect and likely due to external factors.  In fact, Lynn himself did a recent study of South Asians in the United Kingdom and found an average of 95, higher for Indians but lower for Pakistanis.  So Indians were around 100, Pakistanis around 90.  My own studies of Indians in the United States show an IQ that’s even higher - however these are not your average Indians.  The immigration policy of United States brings more bright and talented Indians so they have become the State’s most talented minority, but do not represent the average Indian.  The United Kingdom estimate seems more realistic because the U.K. immigration brings more average Indians into the country.  That’s why normal Pakistanis in the U.K. do poorly, but the Indians still do very well.  For example, they score second highest on GSCE exams (after the Chinese).  This supports the estimate mentioned above.

We can also use Singapore to estimate Indians average IQ.  Indians in Singapore are mostly those who came as laborers, brought in by the British, just like the Chinese.  The measured IQ of Chinese in Singapore is 108, and Malays have a score of 92.  Indians, in all socioeconomic factors, are between the Chinese and Malays, usually inching towards the Chinese.  While they have very high incomes and education rates, their actual examination (test) scores are in the middle between the Chinese and Malays.  So that would enable us to estimate an IQ of around 100 or so.  This matches the earlier estimate.  Of course, India has many ethnic groups.  In my view, Muslim Indians tend to do the worst while Parsees do the best.  Overall, South Indians (darker) do better than North Indians (lighter) but not by much.

The country itself will lag behind China in potential because China is a very uniform country while India is a patched up place of hundreds of different interest groups to fulfill.

-Takahata Joe

Posted by Takahata Joe on Saturday, June 7, 2008 at 04:13 PM | #


kid-1

Your name speaks volumes about your intellectual capacity.  I find it amusing that you “prefer” white doctors even though Indians the UK are, on average, more educated and score higher on tests than whites.

http://www.statistics.gov.uk/cci/nugget.asp?id=461

Not that I don’t understand, of course.  The majority of people do not have the capacity to do research before forming opinions.

Posted by Takahata Joe on Saturday, June 7, 2008 at 04:18 PM | #


The blatant racism on this page is ridiculous! Is it really possible for Africans to have an IQ of 60, when considering that an IQ of 78 is classified as mentally retarded?

Posted by L on Saturday, June 7, 2008 at 10:40 PM | #


“L,” Prof. Rushton addresses your question here.  There’s no contraction although it may seem as if there’s one. 

Lawrence Auster has also dealt with this issue at his site; I haven’t got the exact reference.  If memory serves, he reconciles it in a slightly different way from Prof. Rushton.  But he does reconcile it. 

If you’re interested, here are more Rushton articles.

Posted by Fred Scrooby on Saturday, June 7, 2008 at 10:59 PM | #


That should be, “There’s no contradiction ...”

Posted by Fred Scrooby on Saturday, June 7, 2008 at 11:01 PM | #


Rushton’s analysis seems to be right. Even with Brahmins which are just 5% of India’s population, they can’t pull up a country with so many low IQ people. Probably India is also destined to mediocrity alongwith North Africa and other low IQ nations. I am a (low IQed) Indian who is seriously thinking of migrating to Canada now......... maybe with so many high IQ people around I might learn new things and make little improvements to my low IQ!!! Unfortunately Canadians on average should become dumber if they let me inside their country. My small mind has a humble idea for Dr. Rushton. Why not import all Ashkenazi Jews to the west since they have the highest average IQ. Then surely western countries will become unbeatable. Why dont they start doing it. Anyways maybe I’m too dumb to comprehend such things.

Posted by dumbindian on Monday, June 9, 2008 at 04:53 AM | #


Dear “dumbindian”

If you have an opinion, why hide behind a false identity to say it?

In my opinion, I agree with the original poster of this article that I see no lack of IQ potential from Indians, unlike, say, Africans.  I don’t believe they have the same overall average as East Asians (around 106), but their more pronounced variance can be an advantage.

Posted by Takahata Joe on Monday, June 9, 2008 at 08:23 AM | #


“Why not import all Ashkenazi Jews to the west since they have the highest average IQ.” (—Indian)

Sounds great. 

Except for one thing:  Ashkenazi Jews do to Euro countries what termites do to homes, methodically destroy them from the inside out.  They can’t stop:  it’s in their genes.  So, all Euro countries had best reduce their numbers to a minumum until they show they know how to behave (which, it being in their genes, may never come to pass).

Posted by Fred Scrooby on Monday, June 9, 2008 at 12:46 PM | #


Wow! I just stumbled upon this blog. What is it? Is the new Chinese government propaganda website? Why do the Chinese fear the Indians so much? There seems to be a tremendous inferiority complex going on here. You don’t have to worry my Chinese friends, we Americans will import enough Chinese toys and furnitures to keep you fed. Just don’t go on a brag-trip and tell everyone how smart you are because this website is a testimony to the contrary.Also, for the Indian bloggers on this website, restrict yourselves to solving mathematical problems, designing computer softwares and on answering phone calls. That is your specialization at this point, any argument you guys try to make on this blog does not sound as eloquent or compulsive.

Posted by Kostas Agnelli on Wednesday, June 11, 2008 at 06:54 PM | #


Kostas Agnelli “for the Indian bloggers on this website, restrict yourselves to solving mathematical problems, designing computer softwares and on answering phone calls”

Of course Americans are too busy with attacking other nations for oil.

Lets see for how long that oil is going to last. aaha do I need to mention about the state of US Economy is in?

Posted by vixflix on Monday, June 16, 2008 at 03:10 PM | #


kid-1 wrote
--
the only thing that chinese failed is the english language, chinese english is not as good as the indian in our college, partly bacause chinese kids have been learning it for 2 or 3 years, while the indian are born here
---

In Singapore, where the Chinese have 108IQ ( highest among chinese ) and the chinese have been in singapore for 100 years just like the low caste Indian diaspora in Singapore
The low caste singapore Indian diaspora beats the chinese in English

La Griffe Du Lion has an article where he shows that verbal IQ of east asians is 4 less than whites,
whereas upper caste Indians are trilingual and most of the wall street Analyst jobs have gone to India
Most white collar jobs from call centers to software to general purpose white collar has started to migrate to India

Google up Offshoring and India

Posted by rec1man on Monday, June 23, 2008 at 02:32 PM | #


http://www.indianpediatrics.net/july1999/july-669-676.htm

Low birth weight vs IQ study in Pune

Social and Environmental Assessment

Thirty per cent of the mothers had some degree of college education, whereas one per cent of the mothers were illiterate. Five per cent of the children lived in independent bungalows and the rest in lower and middle class localities. Most of the children (91 %) came from middle or lower middle class families (SES II or III). Fifty six per cent of the children lived in overcrowded houses.

A multiple linear regression analysis was done using IQ as the outcome variable and infant and socio-environmental information as predictor variable. The predictor. variables included socio-economic status, locality, spaciousness of the house, mother’s education, etc., mental and motor age on}3ayley Scales at one year (available from the previous phase of the study), and chronic medical problems like seizures and asthma.

The regression analysis showed that mother’s education (β coefficient 0.33373, p <0.001), spaciousness of the house (β coefficient 0.19424, p <0.020), and a mental age at one year (β coefficient 0.22959, p <0.009) had a significant impact on the 6 year IQ. Chronic medical problems had a negative impact on the 6 year IQ (β coefficient - 0.3573, P <0:020). Multiple R of the final module was 0.4354.

--

IQ = 50-69
Control Group = 0%
Low Birth Weight = 3.5%

IQ = 70-84
Control Group = 5.6%
Low Birth Weight = 13.4%

IQ = 85-110
Control Group = 77.5%
Low Birth Weight = 70.1%

IQ = Above 110
Control Group = 16.9%
Low Birth Weight = 10%

Mean IQ
Control Group = 101

Low Birth Weight = 94

Posted by rec1man on Thursday, June 26, 2008 at 12:58 AM | #


Costas “Is the new Chinese government propaganda website?”

Indians all over the world are lack of confidence…

This IQ stuff is written by the white. Are you telling us the Chinese has commanded European Counries? LOL!

Posted by gpit on Friday, June 27, 2008 at 04:32 PM | #


The same old biased studies and arguments is being rehashed again with some new looks. As others have said in their comments, Richard Lynn has manipulated his data by testing malnourished Indians in remote areas and comparing them to Beijing urbanites to achieve the results he wants, which is not surprising seeing that he is well connected with the Pioneer Fund just as Rushton.
I notice Nick Nguyen post on February 18, 2008 above and I wonder he is the same NickN who got his handed to him at:-
http://www.businessweek.com/globalbiz/blog/globespotting/archives/2007/03/the_trouble_wit.html

Posted by Han on Friday, July 11, 2008 at 03:11 PM | #


him bhai .. are you indian or aryan??  dont bring up aryan theory for real desis .. we should avoid the white supremacy aryan theory. they are the ones who destroyed our ancient civilization..(harappan /indus) aryans were nomadic worriers .. they were like the mongols of the medieval era… u know the mongols re-painted even the ancient iranian chronicle with east asian faces(they are lucky because it happned in the recent years..and could correct well in time).. the same happned to india long long time ago and we never know what was the reality ... the aryans worshped natural forces..and brought in some mythology but there is no proof that hindu culture was something invented by them.  besides no one will accept you as aryan(except for few afghan looking minority) .. why to be a follower .. we are indians ..  today indians are catching up ... and we dont trust the white IQ theories ..these are all memdia stunts !!

Posted by mammu on Saturday, July 26, 2008 at 08:02 PM | #


We brown people are the most peaceful race on this earth!! everyone talk shit about darker people .. just becasue brown people never committed any attrocities to the humanity in the entire history of human civilization. we built civilizations ..indus harappa ... some barbarians (white scholars say they were aryans) destroyed our civilization .. the engineering skills we had .. they committed crime and dispersed our brown people southward .. these criminals started divisive society ..... they re-wrote our history .. well i think the fact is they absorbed most of our civilized culture ... the way mongols became iranians /pakistains /indians ..  if mongols would have been super power today .. they would have theorised totatlly different view of the world… atleast i appreciate genghis khan ..who believed in meritocracy .. blacks /browns /whites ..anyone could rise to high rank.. here we see a lot of crap theories of the brahamins/upper caste ... lets get the shit straight dude .. the whole world knows that most of the engineers/doctors/scientists from india are the original brown people. it’s the concrete proof that brown people in india are IQ lifters!! most people from the north are more related to barbarians.. certainly they have limited IQ ... so here is the actual scale of indian IQ distribution.

Brown/Dravid - 110-120 (indus/harappa..currently the most advanced society engineering/science/ in india)
Nothern india Hindu Barbarians - 90 ( they improved after interaction with the peaceful brown people)
Northern india Muslim barbarians - 80 (they are relatively new barbarians )
White skin entertainment/bollywood barbarians - 60( they are mostly descendants of the Mujra(mughal brothel) artists)

most of the white shit suckers from north ...are all barbarians .. white people why dont you take them with you .. they’ll be really happy to serve u.. but let me worn you they still have barbarian instinct!!!

Posted by mammu on Monday, July 28, 2008 at 12:03 AM | #


“We [Subcontinental] brown people are the most peaceful race on this earth!! everyone talk shit about darker people .. just because brown people never committed any attrocities to the humanity in the entire history of human civilization. [...] Northern india Hindu Barbarians [...] improved after interaction with the peaceful brown people” (—Mammu)

Mammu, what color are the Tamil Tigers?

[Oh ... those links just above?  Just ignore them, they weren’t supposed to be in there.  How’d they get in there??  Don’t click on those, ignore them, OK, they’re not important, don’t read them.]

Right, now ... where were we? ...

... Oh yes, now I remember, I was asking what color, or what shade, dark or light, the Tamil Tigers were ... Any idea? .... If you need to look it up it’s OK, I’ll wait .....was just curious, go ahead .....

Posted by Fred Scrooby on Monday, July 28, 2008 at 01:05 AM | #


mammu: Since you Dravidian types are so cognitively elite, I’m sure you all will have no problem with building up your own economy without dependence on outsourcing from barbarian whitey or immigration to our lands, right?

I think I’ll let the social situation and demographic character of it in India speak for itself.

Posted by Darren on Monday, July 28, 2008 at 02:04 AM | #


Fred you must be a disguise of a north barbarian or a white supremacist who tried to prove all the cool things that happned on te earth were initiated by whites!! hitler formed a team of scholars to research in greece to cliam they were actully from german… the fact is original elite smart greeks had already become turks!! .. so you tell me what is the need for you to prove the barbarians to be smart people.. in that case you should also prove the turks are the smartest people..  i feel pity to see the double standard of the white scholars… i tell you majority of the turks are greek population ... u better accept them as whites.  now regarding color ... u must have the sense of average .. i dont project tamil but average indian ....  observe bengal/maharstra/MP/...... majority are brown .  99% of the talented indians are dark.. 99% parasitic indians are fair skinned. facts can not be changed!!

Posted by mammu on Monday, July 28, 2008 at 07:31 AM | #


Darren bhai you tell me .. why north states are still so backward inspite of being really a huge society!! it’s because the there is still pchychological grip of the barbarians !!  bro if you are a true indian and u have slightest of brown pigments on ur skin ..look at it and try to understand why u hate so much to have those pigments!! u probably must be trying to get a fair girl to get rid of that… this is not your fault but history ... lets make a simple analogy here , take the khan title .. u’ll probably think most khans are aryan origin .. now you find out the origin of khan title !!! u’ll be surprised to see it was introduced by the mongol overloards!! now why should they keep this title if they didnt feel cool about it!!  this is a simple example of pschychological grip imprinted by a powerful but barbarian regime.  the same pchyche is imprinted deeply among our north bros .. this is a major obstacle we indians should try to overcome .. otherwise vast majority of our talents will remain hidden behind the pschycological grip of the barbarians .. 

btw i speak not for dravidians or aryans but on behalf of avegare indian.... i dont believe in the origin theory but a mixing theory… so there is no pint trying to find who are ur roots .. only weak society try to affilate themselves to some powerful group.  we are all mixed .. the whole world is mixed .. there is nothing called completely pure race ... how could white looking ainus be tribalized in northern japan.. the chromegnon men of the america..east asian migration to america.. the migration of the asian huns to europe ..hungary/spain/and other gaul areas.. the arab empire in middle east..migration of the vikings..  there are endless historical facts to prove that everyone is mixed. so be proud to be a mixed race and stand on urself instead of affilating to some obsucure white root theory.

Posted by mammu on Monday, July 28, 2008 at 08:10 AM | #


Mammu, we know that brown people can be smart and pale people can be barbarians.  We just don’t want to get changed into brown people by the present unregulated immigration policies and the array of laws that go with them, laws whose effect is government-enforced artificial elevation of browns over whites in whites’ own countries.  We don’t like that.  We’re not trying to put browns down but if we get angry enough we won’t care what we say and it’ll seem as if we are.

Now, that seems simple enough to understand but right at about this stage in the conversation, the stage where someone on our side says what I just did, namely we don’t have anything against other races, we just don’t want to get changed into them, the member of the other race we’re talking to begins questioning the legitimacy of that next, namely our preferring to remain our own race, unmixed.  If you’re now going to start doing that, Mammu, you’ll persuade no one here, so save your breath.

Posted by Fred Scrooby on Monday, July 28, 2008 at 12:53 PM | #


Mammu, I really don’t care and nobody else does either. What is your point? You have failed to support your arguments. I really don’t care about who is the “superior” race (ultimately, such questions are a pointless waste of time, regardless of who wins and to what standard they proclaim), but you seem to be obsessed over convincing us that brown people are superior without any data beyond your insistence. I’m a “universal nationalist” and wish you and your people well in establishing an ethnostate. The sniping we do at each other, from both sides, doesn’t accomplish anything.

Regarding your argument that we’re all mixed: I don’t proclaim that all Europids are “pure”. I only believe that there are obvious differences between the races (whatever their current genetic state may be) and as such, we have the duty and obligation to future generations to preserve our ethnic genetic interests by avoiding any future race mixing. I don’t believe that (most) Europeans are mixed to any significant degree, but its pointless to get into a debate about what happened in the past. We only have the future to work for. You are spending plenty of time trying to convince us that we’re all part of a barbaric race, so that would seem to imply that you support racial separatism.

Posted by Darren on Monday, July 28, 2008 at 01:24 PM | #


“You are spending plenty of time trying to convince us that we’re all part of a barbaric race, so that would seem to imply that you support racial separatism.” (—Darren)

Darren makes a good point, which often gets made, in one form or another, by people on our side — if we’re barbaric, Mammu, you should agree with our keeping apart:  a person doesn’t normally wish to mix with barbarians.

Posted by Fred Scrooby on Monday, July 28, 2008 at 04:18 PM | #


This point gets made with respect to the perpetual white-Negro problems here in the States:  if whites are so bad, so mean, so unjust, such thieves, rapists, lynchers, so dumb, so much worse-looking physically, and all the rest of it, Negroes should like nothing better than to be separate from whites and finally at long last free to flourish to the full extent of their potential.  Whites would be very happy with that too, so what’s the problem?  Who is it who’s forcing us together when we are unhappy together?  (I’ll bite my tongue rather than divulge the answer.)

Posted by Fred Scrooby on Monday, July 28, 2008 at 04:23 PM | #


Fred , Darren ..i didnt mean to target white ... i never talked about the real whites ... i have been been talking about these bogus whites .. who are irresponsible to the extend that they hate to accept what they actually are. i’m brown ..u can say light in the indian perspective… i know u people like purity .. what about we people who are already mixed .. i’m trying tomake a point that both blaclk and white component in me deserves equal reward without any of which my type never would have existed..  but majority of my type prefer to affilate themselves to white and it’s an obstacle in uniting our society.  partially this is due to publicized aryan thmeory ..which originated during the british colonial time… those days were the days of white supremacist .. these days whites are the most rational people… atleast in those days the indus civilization was forcefully attributed to the aryan theory… our society fell apart competing to be the coolest race .. but now we know that indus civilization didnt belong to aryans ... but by now the aryan theory has become so popular that even 5 year old kid knows about it. 

the problem is incomplete knowledge !! anyone who has partial knowledge of history will be biased .. but once we dig deeper ..we realize that every race has something to be proud about at some point of time in the history.  the mayans , egyptian , mesopotamia , indus , chinese ,greek , roman , british empire , the current civilization dominated by northern european origin… none of them are supreme beings ... it’s matter of time window ... today white people are the focus point ... it could be the black people after 1000 years!

btw beauty is matter of soft power .. it primarily comes from prosperity and well being.. i’m sure if blacks would have been very prosperous , well groomed and whites would have been poor, rugged like the afghan people beuty would have been defined by the standard of black people.  of course we must accept the current reality the....whites are the most civilized race as of today! but i’m not someone who would affilate myself to white.. because i believe in inherent objective property of human… surely i would have been a pro-white if i would have lived in an era when blacks would have been practicing supremacy over whites.

Posted by mammu on Monday, July 28, 2008 at 07:38 PM | #


it’s entertaining to see some of the indians here bashing the chinese and then starting to provoke fights among themselves…
grin The majority of chinese people (or any other east asian people) don’t even speak english and they won’t be able to see this thread in their life time… so stop fighting imaginary enemies my indian friends.

Posted by nakama on Wednesday, July 30, 2008 at 07:01 AM | #


It’s an interesting topic!

I’ve never taken the whole IQ thing too seriously, but I do think that it raises some interesting points. Taken together with other test results such as science and math Olympiad can give us an interesting look into ‘IQ’ as a whole thing.

The East Asians indeed did very well in math and science competitions. Indians perform far less than expected, frequently fall behind Iran, and even Vietnam. Many Indians tend to find excuses for this shortcoming by pointing to poverty and cultural differences. But we’re all know that Vietnam is a poor country, ravaged by wars, manage to outscore India in almost every Olympiad while Vietnam population is only 1/13 of India!. So what’s the culprit? It’s IQ indeed!

By the way, if you don’t like Lynn’s study, there are many opposing and independent researchers on races and IQ.. one come to mind is Robert Lindsay, he pointed out many holes in Lynn’s theory, and also confirm many of Lynn’s findings.  Google “robert Lindsay IQ”

Posted by jonjon on Monday, August 18, 2008 at 09:34 PM | #

Page 1 of 1 pages

Post a Comment:

Name: (required)

Email: (required; will not be displayed)

URL: (optional)

Smileys

# MR's comment software uses session-timing, and may destroy your comment if your browser window
has been left open too long. It's best to copy your comment and refresh the page before submitting it.
# You must prefix http://www.anonym.to/? to gnxp.com links;
For example http://www.anonym.to/?http://www.gnxp.com/...

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Enter the word you see below to submit your comment; you do not need to enter it in order to preview your comment.

captcha shown here

image of the day

Most Recent Comments

torgrim commented in entry 'Frost thawing?' on 08/20/08, 03:00 AM. (#)

Captainchaos commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/20/08, 02:33 AM. (#)

Captainchaos commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/20/08, 02:30 AM. (#)

Captainchaos commented in entry 'Frost thawing?' on 08/20/08, 02:12 AM. (#)

Guest commented in entry 'Frost thawing?' on 08/20/08, 02:06 AM. (#)

Robert Reis commented in entry 'Frost thawing?' on 08/20/08, 01:42 AM. (#)

Robert Reis commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 06:20 PM. (#)

TBX commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 05:54 PM. (#)

Stanley commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 05:17 PM. (#)

James Bowery commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 04:28 PM. (#)

Guessedworker commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 02:20 PM. (#)

Fred Scrooby commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 12:40 PM. (#)

Fred Scrooby commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 12:32 PM. (#)

Fred Scrooby commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 12:30 PM. (#)

Fred Scrooby commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 12:21 PM. (#)

Fred Scrooby commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 11:56 AM. (#)

Fred Scrooby commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 11:54 AM. (#)

Guessedworker commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 11:43 AM. (#)

Fred Scrooby commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 11:41 AM. (#)

2R commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 08:48 AM. (#)

Lurker commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 08:36 AM. (#)

Fred Scrooby commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 04:54 AM. (#)

Fred Scrooby commented in entry 'False Folk Consciousness' on 08/19/08, 03:48 AM. (#)

Fred Scrooby commented in entry 'False Folk Consciousness' on 08/19/08, 03:22 AM. (#)

Fred Scrooby commented in entry 'False Folk Consciousness' on 08/19/08, 02:56 AM. (#)

Fred Scrooby commented in entry 'THE JEWISH SPIRIT AND THE CUBE OF EONS' on 08/19/08, 01:47 AM. (#)

Al Ross commented in entry 'THE JEWISH